Order an Old Fashioned in Wisconsin and you'll get something most of the country has never seen. The brandy Old Fashioned Sweet uses brandy instead of whiskey, topped with soda, fizzy and built for a Friday fish fry.
Why the brandy Old Fashioned Sweet is Wisconsin's house cocktail
This is the state's house cocktail, and Wisconsinites are right to be loyal to it. The story goes back to German immigrants who favored brandy, and a long romance with Korbel that locals will defend to the death. The brandy Old Fashioned Sweet is lighter and more sociable than the whiskey version. It goes down easy on a warm night and it pleases people who think they don't like Old Fashioneds. (The Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet is so tied to the state that it's practically a regional landmark.)
How to build a brandy Old Fashioned Sweet
Chill the glass. Add 2 oz of brandy and one packet of Still Branch, stir a few seconds, add ice, stir for 30. Then top with about 2 oz of lemon-lime soda (7Up or Sprite) and give it five more seconds. Express an orange peel over the top and finish with two Luxardo cherries. The soda lifts the whole thing and the cherries make it feel like a treat. Any decent brandy works, including the same VS or VSOP cognac from the cognac version.
Understand what the soda is doing, because it defines the style. Topping a brandy Old Fashioned Sweet with lemon-lime soda lengthens the drink and drops the proof, which turns a stiff sipper into something you can have two of at a backyard table. It also adds a bright, fizzy sweetness on top of the packet's deeper sugar, so the drink reads playful instead of serious.
The cherries matter more than you'd think. Use real Luxardo or another good Italian marasca cherry, dark and syrupy, not the bright red dyed kind. Drop in two, and let a little of the cherry syrup slide in with them. That syrup is part of the brandy Old Fashioned Sweet in the Wisconsin tradition, sweetening and coloring it from the bottom.
Sweet, sour, or press: ordering a brandy Old Fashioned Sweet
Two variations worth knowing, and Wisconsin bartenders will ask which you want. Make it a Sour by topping with sour mix or a splash of grapefruit soda like Squirt, which cuts the sweetness with tartness. Make it a Press by splitting the topper, half club soda and half lemon-lime, which dries it out. So the full ordering language is "sweet," "sour," or "press," and now you can speak it.
It's a crowd drink, full stop. The brandy Old Fashioned Sweet is the one you build for the friend who usually orders wine, or the family table where not everyone wants a stiff pour of bourbon. The packet keeps the base balanced so the soda and cherries land as a finish instead of a sugar bomb. Make a few at your next gathering and watch them disappear faster than anything else you pour.
What brandy to use in a brandy Old Fashioned Sweet
The Wisconsin classic is Korbel, an American brandy that's a little sweet and easygoing, and locals will tell you it's the only correct choice. In practice, any decent brandy works here: an everyday VS or VSOP cognac, a California brandy like Christian Brothers or E&J, or a Spanish brandy if you want more depth. Because the brandy Old Fashioned Sweet is topped with soda and finished with cherries, you don't need to spend much. The format is forgiving by design, which is part of why it became a high-volume supper-club pour in the first place.
It's also the variation that converts wine drinkers, so it's worth knowing the move. Someone who orders Pinot at every dinner and waves off "brown liquor" will almost always say yes to a brandy Old Fashioned Sweet, because the soda and cherry make it read like a grown-up soda rather than a stiff pour. Hand them one without overselling it, and you've quietly widened what they'll drink at your table. That's the secret weapon of this whole style: it's the friendliest door into the Old Fashioned family.
There's a make-ahead trick that makes a brandy Old Fashioned Sweet even friendlier for a crowd. Stir a batch of the brandy and packets together in a pitcher and keep it cold, then pour over ice and top each glass with soda to order. The fizz stays alive because it goes in last, and every glass lands fresh instead of going flat in a punch bowl. It's the closest thing to having a supper-club bartender in your own kitchen.
It's built for warm-weather gatherings and casual food. Backyard cookouts, fish fries, a tailgate, a pitcher-and-burgers afternoon. The lower proof and the fizz make the brandy Old Fashioned Sweet a drink you can sip across a long, hot day, and it sits happily next to fried food, bratwurst, and anything off a charcoal grill. If you're serving a group, batch the brandy and packets ahead in a pitcher and add the soda and cherries per glass at the last second so the fizz stays alive. A brandy Old Fashioned Sweet is forgiving enough to make in volume, which is exactly why Wisconsin supper clubs pour them by the hundreds on a Friday night. Set out a row of glasses, build the bases ahead, and top each with soda to order. Nobody will guess the balance came from a packet, and you'll move through a crowd faster than any bartender working from scratch.
Add brandy, stir, top with soda. Drop in the cherries. Wisconsin had it right.
Leave a comment