Swap whiskey for agave spirits and the Old Fashioned goes somewhere unexpected and very good. The Oaxaca Old Fashioned is a riff on the modern classic Phil Ward built at Death & Co. in New York back in 2007, and it's one of the most influential cocktails of the last twenty years.
What goes into an Oaxaca Old Fashioned
Aged tequila does the heavy lifting, sun-warmed and a little earthy, and a half ounce of mezcal curls smoke through the whole drink. Two blue agave spirits, one named for Oaxaca (say it wa-HAH-kah), the Mexican state that's the heart of mezcal country. Mezcal is roasted in earthen pits before fermentation, which is where its signature smoke comes from. Reposado tequila is "rested," aged a few months to a year in oak, which gives it a mellow, lightly barreled character that behaves like a young whiskey in a cocktail. That barrel time is why reposado, rather than blanco, is the right choice for an Oaxaca Old Fashioned.
How to build an Oaxaca Old Fashioned
The build holds the same shape as every Still Branch drink. Chill the glass. Add 2 oz of reposado tequila, 0.5 oz of mezcal, and one packet of Still Branch. Stir a few seconds, add ice, stir for a full 30. Express an orange peel over the top and drop it in. The orange oil against the smoke is a small thrill, so don't skip the garnish on this one.
The mezcal is the part to respect. A half ounce is plenty. It's there to season the Oaxaca Old Fashioned, a thread of smoke behind the agave and the packet's bitters, and it should whisper rather than shout. Too much and it takes the wheel. If you're new to mezcal, start with a quarter ounce and work up. You can always add more on the next pour.
On bottles, a midrange reposado like Espolòn, Cazadores, or Siete Leguas makes a great base, and a small accessible bottle of mezcal like Del Maguey Vida is the standard workhorse for this seasoning role. You don't need to spend big. The mezcal especially goes a long way.
Who the Oaxaca Old Fashioned is for
The dark brown sugar and Marasca cherry give the agave something sweet and round to lean on, and the smoke keeps it from getting too friendly. That tension, sweet and earthy and smoky all at once, is what makes the Oaxaca Old Fashioned so memorable. It tastes complex and considered, like a bartender fussed over it, when really you just added two spirits to a packet.
A couple of pointers keep it honest. If your mezcal is bigger and smokier, dial it back to a quarter ounce. If you can only get blanco tequila, it'll still make a good drink, just brighter and more vegetal, so stir a few extra seconds to soften it. Don't substitute a gold "mixto" tequila; you want 100% agave for a drink this exposed.
A gentle way into mezcal
If you've never had mezcal before, the Oaxaca Old Fashioned is a kind and rewarding way in. At a half ounce or less, the mezcal is a background note rather than the main event, so you get acquainted with the smoke without committing to a full pour of it. Plenty of people who think they don't like mezcal discover, through a drink exactly like this, that what they don't like is too much mezcal. A whisper is a different thing entirely, and the packet's sweetness gives that whisper something soft to land on.
Glass and ice play a role here as well. The smoke in an Oaxaca Old Fashioned reads clearest when the drink is cold and slow-melting, so a short rocks glass and one big cube serve it better than a pile of small ones. Quick-melting ice waters the agave down and mutes the mezcal you measured so carefully. Keep it compact and let the smoke stay in focus.
It's also one of the most credible cocktails you can put in someone's hand. The original Oaxaca Old Fashioned has been on serious bar menus across the country for nearly two decades, ever since Phil Ward built it, so serving one signals you know what you're doing. The fact that yours started from a packet and two pours stays your secret. Few drinks deliver that much perceived effort for that little actual work, which is exactly the trick the whole Still Branch lineup is built around.
On food, the Oaxaca Old Fashioned is a knockout next to anything off a grill or anything with chili and char. Carne asada, grilled shrimp, mole, smoked pork, even a good plate of tacos al pastor all meet the smoke and agave head on. It's also a year-round drink: cozy by a fire in winter, bright on a patio in August. This is the Old Fashioned for someone who thinks they've had every Old Fashioned. Hand it to the bourbon loyalist at your next dinner and watch them reconsider. One more reason the Oaxaca Old Fashioned earns a permanent spot: it's genuinely flexible on the agave. A bold, smoky mezcal wants a lighter hand, a softer one can take the full half ounce, and a good reposado does most of the talking either way. Once you find the ratio you like, write it down, because a half ounce of difference is the line between a whisper of smoke and a bonfire. The packet holds everything else steady while you dial that one number in.
Reposado and a whisper of mezcal. Stir, ice, orange peel. Smoke included.
Leave a comment