If you only ever make one drink with a Still Branch packet, make the whiskey Old Fashioned. It's the original, the drink the whole brand is built around, and the one to learn before any variation.
Why the whiskey Old Fashioned is the one to learn first
Whiskey, bitters, sugar, citrus oil, and time on ice. Six ingredients of careful work, and we put five of them in the packet so the only thing left to you is the bottle. It's the oldest cocktail there is, and it's still the one bartenders use to judge each other, because it has nowhere to hide. There's no juice, no cream, no shaken froth to cover a mistake. Get the proportions wrong and you taste it instantly. The skill is the balance, and the balance is the exact thing we measure into every packet. (For the full backstory, the Old Fashioned cocktail dates to the early 1800s and has barely changed, which tells you the formula was right.)
How to build a whiskey Old Fashioned
Chill a rocks glass. Add 2 oz of whiskey and one packet of Still Branch. Stir for a few seconds to combine, add your ice, then stir for a full 30 seconds. That last part matters more than it sounds. The melt rounds the drink off and pulls everything together, and skipping it is the most common reason a home whiskey Old Fashioned tastes harsh. One reviewer stirs hers until condensation beads on the outside of the glass, and that's exactly right. Stir longer than feels necessary.
An orange peel on top is a nice touch if you have one. Take a wide strip, avoid the bitter white pith, pinch it over the glass to express the oils, rub it along the rim, and drop it in. The drink stands fine without it, which is the whole point. You can build this on a kitchen counter, a campsite, or a hotel desk and it lands the same.
A note on ice. Bigger is better. One large cube or sphere melts slower than a handful of small cubes, so the drink chills without watering down too fast. At a campsite or a hotel, whatever ice you can find works.
Choosing the whiskey for your whiskey Old Fashioned
The whiskey is yours to pick, and the choice changes the drink completely. Bourbon runs rounder and softer, with vanilla and caramel from the barrel. Rye gives you more spice and snap and a drier finish. A high-proof bottle brings heat you can feel. A wheated bourbon like Weller keeps it smooth and easy. Same packet, a different whiskey Old Fashioned every time, and all of them balanced because the hard part is already measured into the mix.
A few common mistakes are worth heading off. The first is under-stirring, which we covered. The second is over-pouring the whiskey: two ounces is the number, and eyeballing three makes the drink hot. The third is reaching for cheap, harsh whiskey on the theory that the mix will hide it. The packet flatters good whiskey and exposes bad whiskey, so pour something you'd be happy to sip.
If you want several at once for company, the whiskey Old Fashioned scales cleanly. Multiply the whiskey by the number of drinks, drop in one packet per drink, and stir each glass individually so each gets its own ice and its own 30 seconds. Because the balance is sealed in, the fourth drink tastes exactly like the first.
On food, the whiskey Old Fashioned is a natural before dinner or alongside anything off a grill. The caramel and bitter notes sit beautifully next to steak, burgers, smoked brisket, or a sharp aged cheddar. It's a touch much for delicate fish, but for red meat and anything charred it's close to the ideal pour, and it doubles as the drink you can build four of without leaving the grill for long.
A short history behind the whiskey Old Fashioned
The name itself is a clue to the recipe. By the late 1800s, bartenders were dressing cocktails up with all kinds of liqueurs and flourishes, and a certain kind of drinker started asking for theirs made the old-fashioned way: just spirit, sugar, water, and bitters. That request became the drink's name. So a whiskey Old Fashioned isn't a fancy invention. It's the original template every other cocktail drifted away from, which is exactly why it survived. When you build one with a packet, you're making the same drink those drinkers were asking for, minus the part where you grind sugar against bitters at the bottom of a glass.
Glassware helps more than people expect. A short, heavy rocks glass, sometimes called an Old Fashioned glass for obvious reasons, keeps the drink compact and lets a single large cube sit comfortably. The wide mouth puts the orange oil right under your nose. You don't need crystal, but a glass with some weight makes the whole whiskey Old Fashioned feel more deliberate, which is half of why a drink at a good bar tastes better than the same liquid in a juice glass at home.
Temperature matters as much as the glass. A whiskey Old Fashioned wants to be cold without being drowned, so pull it off your attention while it still tastes like whiskey and not like water. If it warms past that point, a fresh cube brings it right back. Stir, taste, and trust your own mouth over the clock.
Once you've got this one down, every other recipe in this series is a small variation on the same move, so learn it cold and the rest come easy. Pour 2 oz. Stir until the glass fogs. This is the one to learn first.
Leave a comment