Old Fashioned vs Canned Cocktails
Which is worth drinking.
Old Fashioned vs canned comes down to one question: do you want a drink someone designed for a vending machine, or one you build in 30 seconds with the whiskey you actually like? Canned cocktails solved convenience and gave up on craft, fixed at one recipe, one spirit, one strength, and they have to stay cold. Still Branch sits in the slot the can misses. That is the Old Fashioned vs canned story in one line.
You pay for water and packaging.
Cans are heavy and need refrigeration, which makes them a hassle to store and to haul. The spirit inside is whatever the brand chose, usually a neutral base or a value whiskey, at a strength you can't adjust. Once a can is open, it's open.
A Still Branch packet is the mixer: dark brown sugar, sorghum, maple, two bitters, Italian Marasca cherry, and orange, measured to bar spec. You add 2 ounces of the bourbon or rye you prefer, so you control the spirit, the strength, and the quality.
The packets weigh almost nothing, need no fridge, and keep for 12 months. The recipe has won 8 awards from 4 judging bodies, including SIP Awards Platinum 2024 and SIP Awards Double Gold 2023. A can can't say that. Put the Old Fashioned vs canned question to a taste test and the packet wins.
Old Fashioned vs canned: the quick comparison
Your spirit, your strength
You pick the bourbon or rye and how strong it goes. A can is locked at one spirit and one strength, drink it as it comes.
No refrigeration
Packets keep 12 months at room temperature. Canned cocktails have to stay cold, eating cooler space that could hold ice or food.
Travels lighter
Light, sealed, no cooler. A packet goes in a bag, a jacket, or a carry-on. A canned Old Fashioned ships a lot of liquid you didn't need.
Built to show off whiskey
The classic Old Fashioned was made to feature good whiskey. A can buries it under a fixed recipe.
Old Fashioned vs canned: the honest tradeoff
A can is grab-and-go with nothing to add. A packet asks you to supply the whiskey and ice. If you keep a bottle around, the Old Fashioned vs canned choice tips to the packet on taste, flexibility, and storage every time. If you want zero effort and zero supplies, the can has its place.
Questions, answered
Is an Old Fashioned packet better than a canned cocktail?
On the Old Fashioned vs canned call, yes, for taste and flexibility, as long as you keep whiskey on hand. You pick the spirit and strength, and the recipe is award-winning. Cans win only when you have nothing to add.
Do I need to refrigerate Still Branch like canned cocktails?
No. Packets keep 12 months at room temperature. Canned cocktails need to stay cold.
How strong is the drink?
You decide. Add about 2 ounces of bourbon or rye per packet, more or less to taste. A can is locked at one strength.
Does it travel better than cans?
Much better. Packets are light, sealed, and need no cooler, so they go in a bag, a jacket, or a carry-on.
Pour an Old Fashioned with your own whiskey.
Award-winning, no fridge, 12-month shelf life. Your spirit, your strength.
Shop Still Branch